The Corn Refiners Association is apparently tired of everyone talking smack about high-fructose corn syrup, its favorite refined baby. Ads like the one above position anyone who tries to avoid The Syrup as doe-eyed, judgmental idiots who are just following the politically correct herd. The cool people in the ads, the ones you’re supposed to want to be, spout off tortuously wrangled benefits like “it’s made from corn” and “like sugar it’s fine in moderation,” all while smirking at the aforementioned idiots’ idiocy.
We won’t pretend we know the math on the health dangers of high-fructose corn syrup. Even the Mayo Clinic tempers its opinions on that stuff. (And they’re in Minnesota!) Though there is this fairly damning piece.
What we do feel 100% comfortable saying is that these ads suck.
They’re so obviously damage control, overbearing bits of propaganda whose entire message is, simply, cynically, don’t question our product. The setups are so forced, the straw-man stereotypes so offensively dipshitty. Everything in these ads reeks of a boardroom. The pro-syrup patsies sound like they’re reading bullet points off a strategy document, and they probably are.
Fail.
More specifically, the “made from corn” argument, the attempt to link The Syrup back to some semblance of nature, is lame at best and misleading at worst. Made from corn? Plastic is made from corn. Wanna eat it? It’s neither natural nor unique to be made from corn.
The moderation line seems incredibly disingenuous, considering the mind-boggling number of processed food products, some you’d never guess, that have a substantial amount of The Syrup pumped into them. And saying there are “no artificial ingredients” in an ingredient that is created through a highly industrialized process is pretty close to a lie.
Then there’s a whole environmental issue with corn.
Sorry, we lost our sense of humor there for a second. We don’t mean to be sanctimonious. Or boring. Boring is worse.
Look, we understand. They’re a business; they make a product and want to sell more of it. And while some equate them to the tobacco industry, we’re not entirely sure the Corn Refiners Association is ruled by a secretive dark council from somewhere near the Earth’s molten core, exporting evil to the surface dwellers in the name of the evil overlord Zeldor and/or truckloads of cash. (Which actually is, as you know, a reasoned and well-researched portrait of the tobacco industry.)
We just think it would’ve been smarter, maybe, for these guys to not do these awful, obvious and disingenuous ads. Better to keep to your office/underground lair, keep pumping money into lobbyists who keep the government from getting too interested in you, and keep helping the food industry create evermore perplexing, explosively sugary products.

I think it’s hilarious that the woman pushing The Syrup acts just like a cult member while dishing out the unlabeled mystery drinks. That’s the kind of birthday party people leave in either body bags or spaceships.
Get your Nikes on, boys. The mothership will be here any minute.
Trying to be positive: The casting offers a diabolically clever juxtaposition of type. Literate, articulate, liberally-looking minority woman with just a hint of funk (and whom you would expect to mind the HFCS memos) turns out to be a cool Ditto Head who bitch slaps crazyass Kansas soccer mom. OMG!
Message to soccer moms everywhere who might be peeking at Yahoo News Health Alerts: Shut up and drink the Kool Aid.
This spot, while not speaking to all levels of sentient life, might actually nail its client-assigned target right between the eyes. Just a thought, and not that I condone such things.
My wife saw these commercials a few days ago and I couldn’t believe it! Great review of these super slimy adverts and glad to see that Marlin calls them how they see them!
I had to watch this again, because I thought, perhaps I was missing something…
Something else occurred to me, which I just commented about over at slashfood: http://www.slashfood.com/2008/09/08/pro-high-fructose-corn-syrup-tv-ads/
Maybe what’s offensive about this campaign—apart from what I personally see as legalistic, corporate language that borders on misleading—is that it isn’t simply combating negative perceptions about HFCS. It’s combating the people who have those perceptions. There’s a difference.
The takeaway on one level is: these people doubt how wonderful our product is, and they look like complete jackasses. You don’t want to be a complete jackass, do you?
Do you?